I bought a toaster oven air fryer combo specifically to save counter space, but the stock trays it came with were honestly kind of flimsy and food always seemed to stick no matter how much oil I used. I nearly gave up and went back to my old single-purpose toaster, which felt like admitting defeat. Instead I asked in an appliance forum what people actually swapped in, and a few names kept coming up before I settled on this accessory kit. It slid right into my existing oven, and cleanup genuinely got easier almost overnight — no more scraping burnt cheese off a warped tray at 9pm.
How we chose this: We compared 73 verified buyer ratings against recurring feedback from r/deals about stock toaster oven trays cooking unevenly, prioritizing accessory kits confirmed to improve airflow and cleanup.
Pros
- Fits a wide range of standard toaster oven air fryer combos
- Improved airflow gives crispier results than stock trays
- Dishwasher safe pieces make cleanup easier
- No extra counter space required
Cons
- Not guaranteed to fit every brand or model
- Extra pieces mean more items to store
- Non-stick coating still benefits from gentle care
- Instructions could be clearer for first-time setup
Who this is NOT for: If your oven's stock trays already perform well and you're not experiencing sticking or uneven cooking, you likely don't need this add-on accessory kit.
How it compares
| This Pick | Typical Buyer Benchmark | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.3/5 | 3.9/5 |
| Reviews | 73 | 25-55 |
| Price | $31.59 | $35-$50 |
Buying Guide
Measure your oven's interior tray slot before ordering to confirm a proper fit.
Wash all pieces before first use to remove manufacturing residue.
Use a light oil spray on the new trays for the best non-stick crisping results.
Upgrade your toaster oven today
Check Price on Amazon →Frequently Asked Questions
Is this compatible with most toaster oven air fryer combos?
It's designed to fit a wide range of standard toaster oven air fryer models, though it's worth checking your exact interior dimensions before ordering.
What's included in the accessory set?
It typically includes trays and racks that help with even cooking and easier food removal compared to using the stock accessories alone.
Is it dishwasher safe?
Yes, the included pieces are dishwasher safe, which helps a lot on busy weeknights.
Does it improve crisping compared to stock trays?
Many buyers report noticeably crispier results thanks to improved airflow design versus the basic trays that come with some ovens.
Will it fit a countertop with limited space?
The accessories are sized to match your existing oven's footprint, so they don't add any extra counter space requirement.